Plush mattresses from Tuft & Needle, Wolf and Plushbeds deliver comfort and pain relief, plus a plush mattress topper

Best Plush Mattresses:

• PlushBeds Signature Bliss PillowTop Mattress – Best overall
• Tuft & Needle Mint Hybrid Mattress – Best for the most softness
• Wolf 14-Inch Memory Foam Hybrid Plush Pillow Top Mattress – Best for pressure relief  

Best overall

PlushBeds Signature Bliss PillowTop Mattress

Shop at PlushBeds

The PlushBeds Pillow Top mattress is all about luxury comfort with a conscience. It combines the cloud-like softness of a pillow top with the supportive bounce of natural latex, making it a great pick for side and back sleepers who want pressure relief without sacrificing alignment. Eco-friendly buyers will also love that it’s built with certified organic cotton, wool, and latex.

As a side sleeper, I absolutely love this mattress. It’s the perfect amount of plushness with good edge support, and the organic, sustainable sourced materials are so important to me.

One of the biggest selling points is its eco-friendly construction. It’s made with GOLS-certified organic latex, GOTS-certified organic cotton, and wool, which means no chemicals or off-gassing smells. The natural materials also help regulate temperature, so it stays cool and breathable, great for hot sleepers.

Sizes: twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, cal. king, split king | Type: hybrid | Material: organic cotton & organic wool | Layers: 4 | Trial Period: 100 nights | Warranty: lifetime

Worth it if:

You’re a combination sleeper who prioritizes eco-conscious materials

Maybe skip if:

You need deep body contouring like with memory foam

Features

• Organic Latex Comfort Layers: GOLS-certified latex for responsive, pressure-relieving support
• Optional Plush Pillow Top: Adds extra cushioning for a softer, more cloud-like feel
• Individually Wrapped Coils: Provide targeted support, motion isolation, and airflow
• Organic Cotton Cover: Soft, breathable, and GOTS-certified for eco-friendly peace of mind
• Organic Wool Layer: Naturally wicks away moisture and helps regulate temperature
• Cooling Performance: Latex and coils allow airflow for a cooler sleep surface
• Eco-Friendly Build: Made with organic, non-toxic, and sustainable materials
• Luxury Hybrid Design: Combines plush comfort with durable support for long-lasting performance

Best for people who want the most softness

Tuft & Needle Mint Hybrid Mattress

Shop at Amazon

If you’re looking for the plushest mattress Tuft & Needle makes, the Mint Hybrid is it. The adaptive foam layers give you a deep, sink-in feel that hugs your body, while the coil system underneath adds just enough lift to keep things from feeling too marshmallowy. It’s a super cozy, cushiony option, like sleeping on a cloud with a little spring underneath.

Cooling is baked into the design with graphite and ceramic gel in the foam to help pull away heat, plus coils that add some airflow. That said, because this is their softest mattress, it does prioritize comfort over structure. Edge support isn’t as strong as firmer hybrids, so if you like sitting on the edge of your bed or spreading out right to the sides, you might notice some sag.

Overall, this mattress is best for side sleepers who want maximum pressure relief at the shoulders and hips or anyone who loves a soft, sink-in feel. Stomach sleepers and folks who need firmer support might want to skip it, but if “plush and cozy” is your dream bed vibe, the Mint Hybrid totally delivers.

Firmness rating: 3/10 | Sizes: twin, twin xl, full, queen, king, cal king | Type: hybrid | Material: foam | Layers: 6 | Trial Period: 100-night sleep trial | Warranty: yes

Worth it if:

You want the softest mattress out there.

Maybe skip if:

You need edge support.

Features

• motion control
• 4 foam layers
• micro coils
• individually wrapped coils
• cooling

Best for pressure relief

Wolf 14-Inch Memory Foam Hybrid Plush Pillow Top Mattress 

Shop at Amazon

If you’re all about that cloud-like sleep, this is Wolf’s softest mattress, and it shows. With a 3-inch pillow top stacked over nine layers of comfort, it’s like sinking into a luxury hotel bed every night. The gel-infused foam keeps things cushy without feeling swampy, while the individually wrapped coils give just enough support so you don’t feel like you’re falling into a marshmallow.

The cover is designed to stay cool, and all the materials are CertiPUR-US certified, so you can sleep easy knowing it’s free from funky chemicals. This is the kind of mattress that makes you want to sleep in on Saturday and maybe take an afternoon nap too.

At 14 inches tall, you’ll need deep-pocket sheets to make it work. It’s also heavier than your average mattress, so moving it around isn’t exactly fun, but it does have easy to grab handles. If you crave a luxury bed, this is the dreamiest pick.

Firmness rating: 3/10 | Sizes: twin, twin XL, full, queen, king | Type: hybrid | Material: foam | Layers: 9 | Trial Period: 101 nights | Warranty: lifetime

Worth it if:

You need a plush mattress with good pressure relief.

Maybe skip if:

You need a bouncier mattress.

Features

• 3-Inch Plush Pillow Top: Wolf’s softest comfort layer for that cloud-like, sink-in feel
• 9 Comfort Layers: A mix of foams designed to balance softness with light support
• Gel-Infused Memory Foam: Helps with cooling and pressure relief
• Individually Wrapped Coils: Add bounce, motion isolation, and targeted support
• Cooling Cover: Breathable fabric that wicks away heat for a cooler sleep surface
• CertiPUR-US Certified Foams: Made without harmful chemicals or toxins
• 14-Inch Profile: Thick, luxurious build (but requires deep-pocket sheets)
• Plushest Wolf Model: Perfect for side sleepers or anyone who loves extra cushioning

Bottom Line

At the end of the day, the “best” mattress really comes down to your sleep style and what kind of comfort you’re after. If you love that sink-in plushness, the Wolf 14-Inch Hybrid Plush Pillow Top and the Tuft & Needle Mint Hybrid both deliver cozy, cloud-like feels—just know they lean soft and may not be the best for stomach sleepers. If you want something plush and eco-friendly, the PlushBeds Signature Bliss PillowTop gives you organic luxury with a greener footprint.

All three are hybrid builds, which means you’re getting a blend of cushy foam comfort and coil support. The differences come down to vibe: Wolf is indulgently soft, Tuft & Needle is plush but modern and cooling, and PlushBeds is luxe and sustainable.

So whether you want eco-conscious materials, budget-friendly plushness, or just that dreamy “hotel bed” feel, there’s a pick here to help you upgrade your sleep game. Because let’s be honest, life’s too short for bad sleep.

Heads up: This post contains affiliate links. That means if you click and buy, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products I genuinely love and think you will too!